Papa John'S Cheeseburger Pizza Sauce Recipe. Papa johns cheeseburger pizza comes loaded with sizzlin' beef, diced tomatoes, dill pickles, gooey cheese and burger sauce, all on top of. Looking for the ultimate mashup of two classic favorites?

It combines a thin crust pizza dough and a simple pizza sauce that bakes up even better than papa john’s pizza. Copy cat recipes say ketchup mustard mayo mix.